From the author of Edgar Award finalist Grit and The Lies They Tellcomes a tense, atmospheric novel for readers of E. Lockhart and Marieke Nijkamp about friendship, truth, and the creeping fears that can’t be outrun.
Whenever another kid goes missing in October, the Pender kids know what is really behind it: a horrific monster out in the marshes they have named the Mumbler.
That’s what Clara’s new crew tells her when she moves to town: Bree and Sage, who take her under their wing; spirited Trace, who has taken the lead on this year’s Halloween prank war; and magnetic Kincaid, whose devil-may-care attitude and air of mystery are impossible for Clara to resist.
Clara doesn’t actually believe in the Mumbler. But as Halloween gets closer and tensions build in the town, it’s hard to shake the feeling that there really is something dark and dangerous in Pender, lurking in the shadows, waiting to bring the stories to life.

Thank you to HarperCollins and Edelweiss for this ARC! This book was the epitome of a slow burn! We are dropped into a sleepy, small town with an air of tragedy that fills the lungs, hearts, and minds of the friend group we follow.
Clara is desperate to fit in and make friends, and as the daughter of a construction worker who moves from site to site, dragging his family along for the ride, she is well versed in determining personalities and what makes people tick. It’s not long until she worms her way into her neighbor’s life. Bree introduces her to Sage, Trace, and Kincaid; all rich and beautiful characters, and not one of them like the other.
Clara falls for Kincaid, who divulges the secrets of this town’s past. There is an omniscient presence of a supernatural force that is named The Mumbler. Clara plays the part of the stalwart skeptic, but as Halloween approaches (the Mumbler’s favorite season) she is thrown into a horror that she could have never imagined.

I liked the slender man-esque lore in this, but I think what I enjoyed most is the lengths people will go to in order to make sense of the very real things that do go bump in the night. I can assuredly say I did not expect the ending, and I was left on the edge of my seat after every page, waiting alongside these kids to figure out what exactly is terrorizing this town. I recommend this to anyone who enjoys Ti West’s films!
5/5 stars








